DeepShelf · AI literature review

How to Read Literature with DeepShelf: From Long PDFs to Verifiable Notes

When you read several papers with AI, the trouble often starts after the model answers: it states a conclusion but cannot say where the evidence for it is. You compare different conclusions and still cannot find what the original actually says.

Here is one way to read long material with DeepShelf: put the PDFs in a project, then ask. For every conclusion you want to keep, open the citation and look at the original. Papers, industry reports, policy documents, and interview transcripts all work the same way.

First, pin down the question: what we need is a traceable judgment, not a “summary”

“Summarize this PDF” usually returns a tidy overview that reads fine but is hard to use as it is. Before you start, write down the one to three things you want to find out this time, for example:

  • What question does the paper set out to answer?
  • What are the main findings, and which data or experiments support each one?
  • What limits come with the sample, the method, or the assumptions?

1. Create a project and upload the PDFs

Create one project per topic and add the related papers, reports, and appendices. Once processing finishes, you can tick the files to use for each question under Sources on the left.

PDFs with selectable text are located most precisely. Scans, dense tables, and figures can be read too, but recognition can be off, so compare those parts with the original file when you rely on them.

2. Make the question specific

For a single paper, ask for the research question, the subjects, and the main findings, with a citation for each finding and “not found” wherever the paper does not say.

For several sources, ask for each source’s conclusion separately, where they agree and where they conflict, a citation for every point, and no filling in where the sources give no basis. With that agreed up front, you can check the answer point by point as soon as it arrives.

DeepShelf documentation: asking questions · checking citations

3. Click the citation and go back to the original

Each citation number at the end of a sentence is clickable. Click one and the PDF opens on the left, jumps to the page, and highlights the passage.

For sentences going into your notes, especially numbers and causal claims that others may quote later, compare four things with the highlighted passage.

  • Does the source really say this? For example, has “may” become “will”?
  • Does the passage support the whole sentence, or only the first half?
  • Did a condition drop out, such as the sample, the date range, the limits of the method, or the authors’ own caveats?
  • Is this a fact, the authors’ interpretation, or your own inference? Keep the three apart.

4. Write down what you could not find

After one pass there are always questions the sources do not answer. You can ask directly which questions are still open, sorted into the three kinds below. Kept in your notes as a “to verify” list, they show at a glance what has been checked and what has not, whether you come back in two weeks or a colleague takes over.

  • The source does not say.
  • The sources conflict.
  • Outside evidence is needed.

5. Turn the reading into verifiable notes

For each core source, note the question, the findings with their location in the original, your own interpretation, the method and scope, the limits, and the open questions, each in its own place. With several papers, list them on the same dimensions first. Differences in definitions, samples, and date ranges are easy to see side by side and disappear once everything is merged into one synthesis.

To turn a set of notes into something you can hand over, ask DeepShelf for a report based on the discussion, then revise it and export it as Word or PDF. Citations in the report open the original in the same way. Exported files do not carry citation marks, so the checking comes before the export.

DeepShelf reports

Start with one PDF

If you have a paper or report waiting to be read, try it once with that one: create a project, upload the file, ask one question that needs evidence from the source, and open the citation.

Start DeepShelf for free